‘Saint Judy’ Film Review: Michelle Monaghan Plays a Crusading Immigration Lawyer in Timely Drama

Read on: TheWrapTheWrap.

Not all heroes wear capes, and in Sean Hanish’s “Saint Judy,” not all heroes can afford those capes.

Judy Wood (Michelle Monaghan) is a determined and devoted immigration lawyer for her clients. Unfortunately, she’s better at arguing cases than she is at paying bills or spending time with her son, Alex (Gabriel Bateman, “Lights Out”). While she’s a soft-hearted advocate, Judy’s tough when it comes to the courtroom. Monaghan embodies Judy’s attributes into her performance, whether it’s her character’s zealous sense of duty, her persistence in keeping her relationship with her son, or her frazzled exhaustion at the end of the day when there are still so many people still left to help.

In some ways, Judy’s personality sounds so familiar because she shares many qualities with other well-meaning and determined lawyers in movies. Think Atticus Finch from “To Kill a Mockingbird,” a man who believed that justice will prevail over prejudice, or the determined dogged spirit of Erin Brockovich in her namesake movie. In Judy’s case, she takes a special interest in Asefa (Leem Lubany, “Rock the Kasbah”), an Afghani teacher pleading for asylum. If Judy loses her case and Asef is deported, the young woman will likely lose her life for defying the Taliban.

Also Read: Michelle Monaghan Cast in Netflix Drama ‘Messiah’

The film’s events take place in 2003, when the already crumbling immigration system became upended in the wake of 9/11. Common, here playing a counsel on behalf of the state, remorsefully explains the situation for the uninitiated in the audience, describing the branch’s shift from Immigration and Naturalization Services to becoming Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE). However controversial ICE’s conversion into a militarized force has been, the film doesn’t take a political stance on the organization. Judy even calls Common’s character, Benjamin, “one of the good guys.” The first immigration judge (Alfre Woodard) seen in the movie admits her hands are tied on the matter of a ruling, leaving the impression that the people working on this side of law enforcement may mean well but cannot do more for people than what is explicitly permitted.

Fortunately, the movie does dig into the apathy of a system that’s overcrowded and under-regulated. When Judy joins Ray’s (Alfred Molina) practice, she inherits Asefa as a client, and it’s clear that the asylum seeker has been more or less abandoned by the cynical Ray, who has no faith in her case. Asefa was drugged by those in charge of her in the immigration detention center — another group of people who have no interest in helping someone they see as a lost cause — and it’s possible she might have been kept in that state until she was shuffled out of the United States.

Also Read: Alfred Molina, Susanne Bier Elected to Motion Picture Academy’s Board of Governors

Over the course of the film, Ray turns out to be a much more complicated character than when he’s first introduced as a man worried more about collecting payment than about his clients. He later admits he was like Judy once, tenacious and determined to save his clients, before he too was beaten down by the immigration system. The work has hardened his bleeding heart to stone, showing how this complicated, gnarled system can eat those on either side of the courtroom.

Inadvertently, “Saint Judy” arrives at a timely moment in politics, just as calls for a border wall continue and politicians have once again stoked hatred and fear of outsiders. As coordinated political attacks on asylum and refugee statuses escalate, here’s a movie walking viewers through the difficult process while giving a positive depiction of those caught in the system: a man fleeing persecution, a teacher arrested for trying to teach girls to read, a child soldier with PTSD, a licensed doctor unable to practice because of a visa issue, and a father ripped from his family, among many case files. Asefa may the movie’s main example, but several times throughout the film, she extends her situation to that of others in her shoes, especially persecuted women. They face a judgment that could send them to their deaths.

But despite a star-studded cast, a strong performance by Monaghan, and Ben Schnetzer’s scene-stealing moments as rich lawyer’s kid with impressive language skills, “Saint Judy” feels wanting. Richard Wong’s warm cinematography and Hanish’s direction look like fairly standard visions of a Los Angeles-based story. The script from first-time writer Dmitry Portnoy falls into a number of traps of courtroom movies. Many of the movie’s most egregious tropes come out towards the end during (of course) the very important last chance in court to fight for the client.

Also Read: Alfre Woodard’s Prison Drama ‘Clemency’ Heads to Neon for US Rights

Lots of familiar faces show up throughout the movie to support Judy and Asefa and to see if her case will mean a breakthrough for their immigrant communities, somewhat like the court scene in “To Kill a Mockingbird” where the town’s Black community attends to watch the proceedings. Unlike the professional manner of the first trial, these appeals judges don’t take the two women’s case seriously; what a preposterous idea to challenge legal precedent! After the movie spends most of its runtime as a restrained procedural, the wheels come off and the tone rolls away into a standard uplifting inspirational speech.

It’s a letdown for a movie that has its heart in the right place to resort to so many clichés. “Saint Judy” is at its strongest when focusing on the experiences of Judy’s clients, and watching the emotional weight on their shoulders slide off as they open up to her. This gives the movie its sense of purpose and drama. “Saint Judy” not only tells the audience that the burden of proof is on immigrants, that they’re “guilty until proven innocent,” but shows how difficult it is to overcome that situation. For all its good intentions, though, the film is an illustrative tool on just a small corner of the immigration crisis.



Related stories from TheWrap:

That Time Broadcast Networks Declined to Air President Obama’s Primetime Immigration Speech in 2014

Watch Samantha Bee Renovate a House for an Immigration Nonprofit in ‘Love It or List It’ Parody (Video)

Alan Dershowitz Calls Out Tucker Carlson on Immigration Comments to His Face

Stephen Miller Called Out as ‘Immigration Hypocrite’ by His Own Uncle

‘Child’s Play’ Trailer: Chucky’s Back and He’s Gone High-Tech (Trailer)

Read on: TheWrapTheWrap.

The murderous doll Chucky is back and he’s gone high-tech in the first trailer for the reboot of “Child’s Play.”

A contemporary re-imagining of the 1988 horror classic, director Lars Klevberg’s new film follows Karen (Aubrey Plaza), a single mother who gifts her son Andy (Gabriel Bateman) a Buddi doll, unaware of its more sinister nature.

The doll immediately scans Andy’s face, suggesting a high-tech spin on the classic horror franchise, with additional hints about the ominous Kaslan Corporation behind the Buddi dolls. The cast also includes “Atlanta” star Brian Tyree Henry.

Also Read: ‘Chucky’ TV Series in Development at Syfy From Original Creators

Chucky first appeared in the 1988 film “Child’s Play,” which was directed by Tom Holland. The franchise spawned six sequels, the most recent being “Cult of Chucky” in 2017.

In the previous films, the children’s doll becomes possessed by the soul of notorious serial killer Charles Lee Ray — but the new trailer suggests a different, more corporate origin story for his murderous rampage.

Tyler Burton Smith wrote the script, based on characters created by Don Mancini — who wrote all seven of the previous films in the franchise, and directed three of them. Seth Graham-Smith and David Katzenberg produced.

Also Read: How Creepy ‘Annabelle’ Doll Haunted Production – And Why It’s the Anti-Chucky Movie

Last month, SyFy announced plans to create a TV series called “Chucky,” executive produced by Mancini and David Kirschner.

Orion Pictures plans to unleash the “Child’s Play” reboot in theaters on June 21.

Watch the trailer above.

Related stories from TheWrap:

Drake Gets Physical with a Cheesecake in His ‘Child’s Play’ Video (Video)

‘Chucky’ TV Series in Development at Syfy From Original Creators

Jon Stewart Rips CNN to Anchor’s Face By Comparing Network to Horror Icon Chucky (Video)

How Creepy ‘Annabelle’ Doll Haunted Production – And Why It’s the Anti-Chucky Movie

Gabriel Bateman To Star As Andy In MGM’s ‘Child’s Play’ Remake, Joining Aubrey Plaza & Brian Tyree Henry

Read on: Deadline.

Young actor Gabriel Bateman (Lights Out, American Gothic), Parks and Rec alum Aubrey Plaza, and Atlanta star Brian Tyree Henry are set to star in MGM’s Child’s Play remake for Orion Pictures. Bateman will take on the role as Andy, Plaza wil…

Bryan Cranston On Making Family Comedy ‘The Dangerous Book For Boys’: “I Wanted To Bring Some Hope To The World”

Read on: Deadline.

Conn and Hal Iggulden’s bestselling guide to boyhood seems like an odd candidate for a television adaptation. It is, after all, a non-fiction how-to with no narrative to speak of. And yet, for Bryan Cranston and his Moon Shot Entertainment production c…

‘Dangerous Book For Boys’: Bryan Cranston & Greg Mottola’s Family-Friendly Adaptation Promises Lo-Fi Charm – The Contenders

Read on: Deadline.

The cast and creators of Amazon’s forthcoming series The Dangerous Book For Boys took the stage to kick of this year’s Emmy Contenders. Show co-creators Bryan Cranston and Greg Mottola were joined on stage by stars Erinn HayesGabriel Bateman, and Swoosie Kurtz to talk about what to expect from the series based on the book by Conn and Hal Iggulden.
One of the driving inspiration behind the adaptation is the fact that Cranston and Mottola are both dads.  “It’s a true…